The relationship between the Natural Wine Movement and the concept of “orange wines” is a complex and intertwined one. Both movements share a focus on minimal intervention winemaking practices and a desire to produce wines that are authentic, expressive of terroir, and reflective of the grape variety. However, there are some key differences between the two that set them apart.
Key Similarities
-
Both the Natural Wine Movement and orange wines are characterized by minimal intervention winemaking practices.
-
They both prioritize sustainable and organic farming methods in the vineyard.
-
Both movements seek to produce wines that are a true expression of the grape variety and the terroir in which they are grown.
Key Differences
-
While all orange wines are considered natural wines, not all natural wines are orange wines. Orange wines are a subset of the broader natural wine category.
-
Orange wines are characterized by their unique production method involving extended skin contact during fermentation, resulting in their distinctive orange hue. Natural wines, on the other hand, can be made in a variety of styles and colors.
-
The Natural Wine Movement encompasses a wider range of winemaking practices beyond just orange wines, including minimal use of additives, spontaneous fermentation, and low sulfite levels.
Origins of the Natural Wine Movement
The Natural Wine Movement emerged in response to the industrialization and homogenization of winemaking practices in the 20th century. Winemakers began to rebel against the use of chemicals, additives, and overly technological processes in the cellar, opting instead for a more hands-off approach that allowed the wine to express its true character.
Origins of Orange Wines
Orange wines have their roots in ancient winemaking traditions, particularly in countries like Georgia and Slovenia, where the practice of fermenting white grapes with their skins dates back thousands of years. This method imparts tannin, color, and texture to the wine, resulting in a unique and distinctive style.
Overlap and Influence
While orange wines are just one subset of the Natural Wine Movement, they have played a significant role in shaping the movement’s ethos and philosophy. The focus on minimal intervention winemaking, organic farming, and authenticity that characterizes orange wines has been embraced by many natural winemakers around the world.
Challenges and Criticisms
-
Some critics argue that the orange wine trend is just a passing fad, driven more by novelty and marketing than genuine quality.
-
Others question the appeal of orange wines, citing their unconventional flavors and textures that may not be to everyone’s taste.
-
There is also debate within the Natural Wine Movement about the definition and boundaries of what constitutes a natural wine, with some purists arguing that orange wines may not fit neatly within this framework.
Future Trends
Despite these challenges, both the Natural Wine Movement and orange wines continue to gain popularity and recognition among consumers and wine critics alike. As more winemakers embrace sustainable and organic practices, and as consumer demand for authentic, artisanal wines grows, the influence of both movements is likely to expand.